Justice for Dr Manjula Arora

My project

The Doctors’ Association UK are looking to gather support for a doctor recently sent to tribunal, whom we strongly suspect has been subjected to unfair treatment because, like countless others, she is from an ethnic minority. As stated in the tribunal, Dr Manjula Arora was suspended for the fact that when she asked for a laptop for work purposes, she was told her interest was noted, but she took that to mean it was being promised to her. She used the word promised when next asking for a laptop and this has resulted in her being found dishonest, and thus being suspended for one month. This, it seems, was enough to warrant medical suspension.

DAUK wants to know why this even got as far as the GMC, let alone resulted in a suspension, for yet another doctor with overseas training. We, alongside the British Association of Physicians of Indian Origin (BAPIO), have written to the Professional Standards Authority (PSA) asked them to review this case urgently and the GMC have since announced a case review.

The PSA have said they will be looking at Mrs Arora’s case and have asked for feedback. Please add your voice to the support, directly to the PSA.

Press Coverage

This case has attracted a lot of attention!

The Independent

The BMJ and a more recent Summary in the BMJ about progress.

The Times (Paywall)

Pulse

And now there is to be an Appeal…!

Manjula will be appealing against this decision, as reported in GP Online with the backing of the MDU – and of course continued support from ourselves.

We Are the Voice of Frontline Doctors – We Make a Difference

We welcome the news about an appeal – having backed Malila from the start

Join Us

You can view the MPTS hearing summary here.

Please sign our letter to the PSA, and leave messages of support below for Mrs Arora, who needs the support of the medical community at this incredibly difficult time.

Write a new entry in our Wall of Support

 
 
 
 
 
 
Fields marked with * are required.
Your E-mail address won't be published.
It's possible that your entry will only be visible on the page after we have reviewed it.
We reserve the right to edit, delete, or not publish entries.
All entries that are approved will be publicly visible.
81 entries.
Dr Philip Mitchell from Lincoln wrote on June 9, 2022 at 4:49 pm
You have my support and understanding, pleased to hear you are challenging this verdict. I recall a number of years ago the GMC made a big deal about how they were screening referrals more effectively to focus on patient safety issues leaving these sort of issues to be resolved locally. Clearly the GMC are incapable of changing their ways despite wasting a load of our fees on the consultation events and publishing of guidelines. Shame on the team who should have passed this straight back to the referring organisation.
You have my support and understanding, pleased to hear you are challenging this verdict. I recall a number of years ago the GMC made a big deal about how they were screening referrals more effectively to focus on patient safety issues leaving these sort of issues to be resolved locally. Clearly the GMC are incapable of changing their ways despite wasting a load of our fees on the consultation events and publishing of guidelines. Shame on the team who should have passed this straight back to the referring organisation.
Dr Anonymous from Cardiff wrote on June 7, 2022 at 1:34 pm
Another reason why the GMC has failed us - It needs an overhaul from top to down. Are the decision makers ever held accountable like all of us?
Another reason why the GMC has failed us - It needs an overhaul from top to down. Are the decision makers ever held accountable like all of us?
Anonymous from London wrote on June 7, 2022 at 1:09 pm
It’s appalling & unbelievable how GMC treats the doctors. Dr Arora’s case is not the first and it won’t be the last. In the past BMA has declared no confidence against GMC twice but nothing has changed. In the recent report from GMC 29 doctors have died during the GMC investigation in the past 2 years. This is atrocious. They put most of the investigation under a blanket dishonestly and make a mountain out of a molehill and completely destroy the doctors lives. GMC should only be given powers to act on clinical concerns regarding patient safety and nothing else. These enormous powers they have to investigate everything should be stripped off them. Until the union and doctors wake up this will sadly continue.
It’s appalling & unbelievable how GMC treats the doctors. Dr Arora’s case is not the first and it won’t be the last. In the past BMA has declared no confidence against GMC twice but nothing has changed. In the recent report from GMC 29 doctors have died during the GMC investigation in the past 2 years. This is atrocious. They put most of the investigation under a blanket dishonestly and make a mountain out of a molehill and completely destroy the doctors lives. GMC should only be given powers to act on clinical concerns regarding patient safety and nothing else. These enormous powers they have to investigate everything should be stripped off them. Until the union and doctors wake up this will sadly continue.
Alice F from London wrote on June 6, 2022 at 1:06 pm
An awful and scarring personal experience, inflicted for the most farcical of reasons. It’s beyond pathetic that this was allowed to happen as it did, seems the GMC lost sight of its real purpose quite some time ago now. I can only echo those who cynically say it’s a way of keeping the GMC’s lawyers in money - this is hardly the first case where the public would not have been ‘protected’ or served in any what whatsoever, regardless of the outcome. The only beneficiaries of this pointless pursuit are the legal team, and they leave a lot of suffering in their wake.
An awful and scarring personal experience, inflicted for the most farcical of reasons. It’s beyond pathetic that this was allowed to happen as it did, seems the GMC lost sight of its real purpose quite some time ago now. I can only echo those who cynically say it’s a way of keeping the GMC’s lawyers in money - this is hardly the first case where the public would not have been ‘protected’ or served in any what whatsoever, regardless of the outcome. The only beneficiaries of this pointless pursuit are the legal team, and they leave a lot of suffering in their wake.
Yvette Jones from Exeter wrote on June 6, 2022 at 12:09 pm
Dear Dr Arora…. What has happened to you is unbelievable …. it exposes a highly dysfunctional system of Doctor regulation … and possibly ingrained racism. I am so sorry for the stress you will be experiencing and hope things can be resolved soon
Dear Dr Arora…. What has happened to you is unbelievable …. it exposes a highly dysfunctional system of Doctor regulation … and possibly ingrained racism. I am so sorry for the stress you will be experiencing and hope things can be resolved soon
Lynn thompson from Bristol wrote on June 6, 2022 at 10:22 am
Absolute madness. Please don’t give up. We need you.
Absolute madness. Please don’t give up. We need you.
Helen Brown from Southend wrote on June 6, 2022 at 10:16 am
This is an unjust act on the part of the employer and facilitated by the GMC and MPTS. Please pass on my best wishes to Dr Arora and her family.
This is an unjust act on the part of the employer and facilitated by the GMC and MPTS. Please pass on my best wishes to Dr Arora and her family.
Becky Sales from London wrote on June 4, 2022 at 8:47 pm
I’m so sorry that this happened to you, and I’m so glad you are fighting it. I’m ashamed to say that the medical profession and it’s regulatory bodies remain racist. Please know that we are with you, in what I can only say is the most ridiculous fitness to practice case that I have ever seen. A Fellow GP x
I’m so sorry that this happened to you, and I’m so glad you are fighting it. I’m ashamed to say that the medical profession and it’s regulatory bodies remain racist. Please know that we are with you, in what I can only say is the most ridiculous fitness to practice case that I have ever seen. A Fellow GP x
Pippa Vincent from London wrote on June 2, 2022 at 7:39 pm
So sorry for the stress your employers put you through and the GMC made worse. Hope you're ok.
So sorry for the stress your employers put you through and the GMC made worse. Hope you're ok.
Dr Vineet Bhat from Cardiff wrote on June 2, 2022 at 7:35 pm
Dear Dr Arora, I am shocked but not surprised at the GMC decision in your case. Whenever there is a case no matter how frivolous the complaint, the first thing they do is throw the doctor under the bus. For all their policies (which is not worth the paper they are written on) there is no support for the doctor. In your case there was no patient related issues at all and the whole case hinged on the word 'promised'. This was a kangaroo court in a banana Republic and the final outcome was so ridiculous that this has caused an uproar in the medical profession and rightly so. We pay huge sums of money to this defunct organisation who now are essentially guardians of the Oxford Dictionary! It's time this organisation is disbanded.
Dear Dr Arora, I am shocked but not surprised at the GMC decision in your case. Whenever there is a case no matter how frivolous the complaint, the first thing they do is throw the doctor under the bus. For all their policies (which is not worth the paper they are written on) there is no support for the doctor. In your case there was no patient related issues at all and the whole case hinged on the word 'promised'. This was a kangaroo court in a banana Republic and the final outcome was so ridiculous that this has caused an uproar in the medical profession and rightly so. We pay huge sums of money to this defunct organisation who now are essentially guardians of the Oxford Dictionary! It's time this organisation is disbanded.
Jonathan C P Roos from London wrote on June 2, 2022 at 5:05 pm
This is why certain types of people cannot be given too much power.
This is why certain types of people cannot be given too much power.
Malini Wace from Newmarket wrote on June 2, 2022 at 1:41 pm
Appalling case of miscarriage of justice. Disproportionate and should have been thrown out at the outset.. With a manpower crisis, this alienates doctors especially those from ethnic minorities who have been vital in propping up General Practice. We support you, Dr Arora.
Appalling case of miscarriage of justice. Disproportionate and should have been thrown out at the outset.. With a manpower crisis, this alienates doctors especially those from ethnic minorities who have been vital in propping up General Practice. We support you, Dr Arora.
Matt Bigwood from Northampton wrote on June 2, 2022 at 1:32 pm
It’s such a terrible injustice you have faced. We are behind you 100%
It’s such a terrible injustice you have faced. We are behind you 100%
Dr Chikkanna Manju from Cheltenham wrote on June 2, 2022 at 8:12 am
The handling of Dr A case is a disgrace, at times when GP services are under so much pressure and strain. Not best use of our registration fees. Stay strong Dr Arora.
The handling of Dr A case is a disgrace, at times when GP services are under so much pressure and strain. Not best use of our registration fees. Stay strong Dr Arora.
Mr Hirron Fernando from Glasgow wrote on June 2, 2022 at 7:09 am
This is another example of poor decision made by the GMC, even after many landmark cases, where The appeal was granted by the high court , GMC as a regulator still hasn’t learn the lessons. We are United as doctors against discrimination of the GMC. I am sure justice will finally prevail yet another poor decision by the GMC
This is another example of poor decision made by the GMC, even after many landmark cases, where The appeal was granted by the high court , GMC as a regulator still hasn’t learn the lessons. We are United as doctors against discrimination of the GMC. I am sure justice will finally prevail yet another poor decision by the GMC
Akila Sylvanus from Newport wrote on June 2, 2022 at 6:53 am
This case should have been resolved locally without getting to GMC. I feel the punishment is too harsh for such trivial offence.
This case should have been resolved locally without getting to GMC. I feel the punishment is too harsh for such trivial offence.
Anoynomous from UK wrote on June 2, 2022 at 3:14 am
This is nonsense - a ploy for barristers on either sides to remain employed : The more " appreances " before the MPT : The more they get paid : esp for full day " jobs" : as medics " fight" amongst themselves about trivial matters : barristers ( non medics) have a field day , draining their money. Even parents : say things like " I promise.." and then forget ! It is human. The whole world is " dishonest" in the eyes of these corrupt barristers !!
This is nonsense - a ploy for barristers on either sides to remain employed : The more " appreances " before the MPT : The more they get paid : esp for full day " jobs" : as medics " fight" amongst themselves about trivial matters : barristers ( non medics) have a field day , draining their money. Even parents : say things like " I promise.." and then forget ! It is human. The whole world is " dishonest" in the eyes of these corrupt barristers !!
Dr Anna Passmore from Bedford wrote on June 1, 2022 at 11:29 am
Shocked and appalled at how you have been treated. Wishing you much strength for the days ahead.
Shocked and appalled at how you have been treated. Wishing you much strength for the days ahead.
Umair Falak from Newcastle wrote on June 1, 2022 at 7:50 am
I find this case entirely ridiculous, why it was not immediately dismissed by the GMC is beyond me . I feel the GMC and the tribunal needs to answer these questions.
I find this case entirely ridiculous, why it was not immediately dismissed by the GMC is beyond me . I feel the GMC and the tribunal needs to answer these questions.
Andrew Carnegie from Chippenham wrote on June 1, 2022 at 7:41 am
I’m appalled at this case, the GMC appears to have made a serious error. From the evidence seen the conclusion would fail the test of the man on the Clapham omnibus. An average person would conclude there was an intent to supply. If this has occurred due to Dr Manjula Arora being non English then it’s racism. I would have assumed that the email intended a supply of a laptop had it been sent to me and had I sent it to an employee I would accept it showed my intention to supply. There is reasonable doubt exhibited. I sincerely hope the GMC reconsider this flawed verdict.
I’m appalled at this case, the GMC appears to have made a serious error. From the evidence seen the conclusion would fail the test of the man on the Clapham omnibus. An average person would conclude there was an intent to supply. If this has occurred due to Dr Manjula Arora being non English then it’s racism. I would have assumed that the email intended a supply of a laptop had it been sent to me and had I sent it to an employee I would accept it showed my intention to supply. There is reasonable doubt exhibited. I sincerely hope the GMC reconsider this flawed verdict.
Dr Sonia Chester from London wrote on June 1, 2022 at 3:06 am
Please challenge this appalling verdict. Shocked GMC ever thought it appropriate to allow this case to get as far as a fitness to practice hearing. Know your colleagues support you & hope you are comforted by the outcry about the way you have been treated so unfairly.
Please challenge this appalling verdict. Shocked GMC ever thought it appropriate to allow this case to get as far as a fitness to practice hearing. Know your colleagues support you & hope you are comforted by the outcry about the way you have been treated so unfairly.
Leyla from Liverpool wrote on June 1, 2022 at 12:50 am
We’re here for you Dr Arora! Well done to DAUK for supporting Dr Arora in this terrible situation. I’m sorry it has got to this point. No Trust should work with Mastercall and they must be held accountable for their actions!
We’re here for you Dr Arora! Well done to DAUK for supporting Dr Arora in this terrible situation. I’m sorry it has got to this point. No Trust should work with Mastercall and they must be held accountable for their actions!
Anum Asim from Birmingham wrote on May 31, 2022 at 11:05 pm
Got me worried about our regulatory body if it is fit to function. Caused so much stress to a dr unnecessarily.
Got me worried about our regulatory body if it is fit to function. Caused so much stress to a dr unnecessarily.
Tia MacGregor from Oxfordshire wrote on May 31, 2022 at 9:57 pm
The GMC shows its true colours yet again. The GMC don’t support doctors much in any case… and should you have the misfortune to be BAME just forget any expectation of fair and equitable treatment. Why do we pay for these people?
The GMC shows its true colours yet again. The GMC don’t support doctors much in any case… and should you have the misfortune to be BAME just forget any expectation of fair and equitable treatment. Why do we pay for these people?
Dr Sumita Kanwar from Ilford wrote on May 31, 2022 at 9:57 pm
I feel this is very harsh It should not have gone to GMC at the first place
I feel this is very harsh It should not have gone to GMC at the first place
Dr Phil Whitaker from Radstock wrote on May 31, 2022 at 8:29 pm
Appalled at how you’ve been treated, and fully supportive of all efforts to bring you justice. I can only imagine how grim things must be at the moment but be assured your profession stands with you.
Appalled at how you’ve been treated, and fully supportive of all efforts to bring you justice. I can only imagine how grim things must be at the moment but be assured your profession stands with you.
M. Prabhu from Heanor Derbyshire wrote on May 31, 2022 at 6:51 pm
Ref: GMC vs Dr. Arora. Medical profession has been protesting for years about the procedures followed and outcomes in this organisation. Now time has come to discuss politically, how to reform the function of regulating any profession for the safety of the public. Medical personal and the public should be encouraged to write to their MP's, so that this matter is discussed in the Parliament. As per the legal profession dragging the procedure for financial gain beyond the point of discussion should be curtailed. Why did this word "PROMISE" to 10 days of talking?
Ref: GMC vs Dr. Arora. Medical profession has been protesting for years about the procedures followed and outcomes in this organisation. Now time has come to discuss politically, how to reform the function of regulating any profession for the safety of the public. Medical personal and the public should be encouraged to write to their MP's, so that this matter is discussed in the Parliament. As per the legal profession dragging the procedure for financial gain beyond the point of discussion should be curtailed. Why did this word "PROMISE" to 10 days of talking?
Audrey Todd from Glasgow wrote on May 31, 2022 at 6:41 pm
A totally inappropriate decision by an organisation which seems increasingly out of touch with reality. Why they didn't simply throw out this petty complaint beggars belief. Dr Arora, you have my full support.
A totally inappropriate decision by an organisation which seems increasingly out of touch with reality. Why they didn't simply throw out this petty complaint beggars belief. Dr Arora, you have my full support.
Dr Sabih Huq from Wick wrote on May 31, 2022 at 6:36 pm
Very poor judgement displayed by a number of people in positions of power: Dr B., the GMC & MPTS. Such a trivial matter, hinging on a single word "promise", which is open to such a wide range of interpretation, should never have been an issue over which a hard-working doctor was suspended. The regulatory system is vindictive and unjust. I have lost all confidence in it.
Very poor judgement displayed by a number of people in positions of power: Dr B., the GMC & MPTS. Such a trivial matter, hinging on a single word "promise", which is open to such a wide range of interpretation, should never have been an issue over which a hard-working doctor was suspended. The regulatory system is vindictive and unjust. I have lost all confidence in it.
Adnan Sharaf from SHREWSBURY wrote on May 31, 2022 at 6:17 pm
Please look after yourself
Please look after yourself
Adnan Sharaf from SHREWSBURY wrote on May 31, 2022 at 6:16 pm
Terrible to read this. I cannot understand how this is happened.
Terrible to read this. I cannot understand how this is happened.
Susan Duncan from Edinburgh wrote on May 31, 2022 at 6:06 pm
Dear Dr Arora I can only marvel at the oppressive bureaucracy that is the GMC. To suspend a doctor with a previously unblemished career shows that David Graeber's analysis of Bullshit Jobs in his book of the same name was prescient and accurate. The actions of the GMC in you case confirm his thesis of the rise of meaningless bureaucratic jobs and the damage they do not only to the people affected by these bureaucracies but to the bureaucrats themselves. If it is any consolation you have and will have a meaningful career where you have helped people and done some good for your fellow man. The same cannot be said of Charlie Massey or the people on your panel who found against you. Be strong
Dear Dr Arora I can only marvel at the oppressive bureaucracy that is the GMC. To suspend a doctor with a previously unblemished career shows that David Graeber's analysis of Bullshit Jobs in his book of the same name was prescient and accurate. The actions of the GMC in you case confirm his thesis of the rise of meaningless bureaucratic jobs and the damage they do not only to the people affected by these bureaucracies but to the bureaucrats themselves. If it is any consolation you have and will have a meaningful career where you have helped people and done some good for your fellow man. The same cannot be said of Charlie Massey or the people on your panel who found against you. Be strong
Dr Paul Bailey from Mulhouse wrote on May 31, 2022 at 5:31 pm
For the GMC's lawyer to describe Dr B's e-mail as “entirely unambiguous” is patently false; it appears he was trying to fob her off with a vague undertaking. Dr Arora clearly felt that she needed a laptop for her clinical work. For Dr B to deny her one seems to me to be in breach of medical ethics. Perhaps he should be reported to the GMC.
For the GMC's lawyer to describe Dr B's e-mail as “entirely unambiguous” is patently false; it appears he was trying to fob her off with a vague undertaking. Dr Arora clearly felt that she needed a laptop for her clinical work. For Dr B to deny her one seems to me to be in breach of medical ethics. Perhaps he should be reported to the GMC.
David Saunders wrote on May 31, 2022 at 5:06 pm
I have read the MPTS the full report on your case. A more ridiculous, nonsensical and illogical judgement it is difficult to imagine. What makes it even worse is that this should never have even reached the GMC in the first place. Shame on whoever referred you. Shame on the case screeners and shame on the tribunal members. All concerned need to reflect very carefully on their involvement in this debacle. Please know that thousands of doctors are supporting you.
I have read the MPTS the full report on your case. A more ridiculous, nonsensical and illogical judgement it is difficult to imagine. What makes it even worse is that this should never have even reached the GMC in the first place. Shame on whoever referred you. Shame on the case screeners and shame on the tribunal members. All concerned need to reflect very carefully on their involvement in this debacle. Please know that thousands of doctors are supporting you.
James Courts from Gold Coast wrote on May 31, 2022 at 4:08 pm
Yet again the bloated and self indulgent regulator demonstrates its lacks of compassion and kindness, despite a growing list of failures it answers to none. At the very most this was an internal work dispute. The MTPS members and those who started this sorry referral should hang their heads in shame and consider their positions forthwith.
Yet again the bloated and self indulgent regulator demonstrates its lacks of compassion and kindness, despite a growing list of failures it answers to none. At the very most this was an internal work dispute. The MTPS members and those who started this sorry referral should hang their heads in shame and consider their positions forthwith.
Swapna Kongara from Preston wrote on May 31, 2022 at 2:42 pm
My sincere thanks to DAUK for supporting Manjula. I sincerely hope that this will not only lead to a positive outcome for Manjula, but also serves as a wake-up call to local organisations and GMC in terms of treating doctors kindly, fairly and justly. Keep rocking!!
My sincere thanks to DAUK for supporting Manjula. I sincerely hope that this will not only lead to a positive outcome for Manjula, but also serves as a wake-up call to local organisations and GMC in terms of treating doctors kindly, fairly and justly. Keep rocking!!
Swapna Kongara from Preston wrote on May 31, 2022 at 2:35 pm
Dear Manjula, I am writing to express my full support to you. I know how much impact such things can have on a doctor's personal and professional life. But stay strong and fight this unfairness and injustice. We are all behind you. There is no excuse for things to have reached this stage. A complete overhaul of investigatory processes at local and GMC level is needed. I sincerely hope that the medical community will not stop fighting until such reformation. But for now, I want to say, believe in yourself and keep fighting. This shall pass too. All the Best!!
Dear Manjula, I am writing to express my full support to you. I know how much impact such things can have on a doctor's personal and professional life. But stay strong and fight this unfairness and injustice. We are all behind you. There is no excuse for things to have reached this stage. A complete overhaul of investigatory processes at local and GMC level is needed. I sincerely hope that the medical community will not stop fighting until such reformation. But for now, I want to say, believe in yourself and keep fighting. This shall pass too. All the Best!!
gillian collister from glasgow wrote on May 31, 2022 at 9:59 am
I read no evidence in report as to why the GMC was being asked or felt required to deal with this . This must have been /is a very distressing time for you . Best wishes to you
I read no evidence in report as to why the GMC was being asked or felt required to deal with this . This must have been /is a very distressing time for you . Best wishes to you
Kathleen Spence from York wrote on May 31, 2022 at 9:23 am
This is a disgraceful display of racism. After a long unblemished career, to be hauled in front of the GMC for misinterpreting an email regarding a laptop? This is cruel. I cannot imagine how Dr Arora must feel right now.
This is a disgraceful display of racism. After a long unblemished career, to be hauled in front of the GMC for misinterpreting an email regarding a laptop? This is cruel. I cannot imagine how Dr Arora must feel right now.
Shahzaman Ganai from London wrote on May 31, 2022 at 9:21 am
Its very unfortunate, how does the GMC continue to do this. They should resend this decision and work towards being a mkre neutral authority. The doctors are also a part of the public that the GMC seems to be protecting the interest of. There should be more scrutiny on the executives, considering the pay that they get compared to doctors.
Its very unfortunate, how does the GMC continue to do this. They should resend this decision and work towards being a mkre neutral authority. The doctors are also a part of the public that the GMC seems to be protecting the interest of. There should be more scrutiny on the executives, considering the pay that they get compared to doctors.
Dr H Sungum from Bridgend in Wales wrote on May 31, 2022 at 12:51 am
A lot of time, energy and resources wasted yet again over a matter that could be clarified via GOOD communication channels. Terribly disappointed that it went this far, but let justice prevail. Hang in there, with kindness and love, huge supportive wishes
A lot of time, energy and resources wasted yet again over a matter that could be clarified via GOOD communication channels. Terribly disappointed that it went this far, but let justice prevail. Hang in there, with kindness and love, huge supportive wishes
Dr P Baird from Guildford wrote on May 30, 2022 at 10:28 pm
Dear Dr Arora: I hope this injustice gets sorted soon, all BAME are with you. Be strong, we are here to help each other! Patricia
Dear Dr Arora: I hope this injustice gets sorted soon, all BAME are with you. Be strong, we are here to help each other! Patricia
Dr Lizzie Toberty wrote on May 30, 2022 at 8:00 pm
Having read the report, I honestly thought I had missed something, but no this really was as outrageous as it sounded. I'm so sorry you have been through this, it's not fair and points to huge failings in the whole system. You have the full support of the profession behind you Dr Arora.
Having read the report, I honestly thought I had missed something, but no this really was as outrageous as it sounded. I'm so sorry you have been through this, it's not fair and points to huge failings in the whole system. You have the full support of the profession behind you Dr Arora.
Dr Rajani Nalluri from Manchester wrote on May 30, 2022 at 7:20 pm
Unbelievable reason for suspension! Unfair treatment of doctor from evening ethnic community
Unbelievable reason for suspension! Unfair treatment of doctor from evening ethnic community
Dr Rosanne Murray from Glasgow wrote on May 30, 2022 at 7:02 pm
So so sorry you have been put through this ordeal. Of course you should have the equipment you need to do your job...without having to plead or "exaggerate" your need! Your case illustrates that GMC needs to be more aware of biases inherent within it's structure, and must use our fees more wisely. That this minor miscommunication got as far as the GMC is deeply troubling. The fact that it was not immediately thrown out is even more so.
So so sorry you have been put through this ordeal. Of course you should have the equipment you need to do your job...without having to plead or "exaggerate" your need! Your case illustrates that GMC needs to be more aware of biases inherent within it's structure, and must use our fees more wisely. That this minor miscommunication got as far as the GMC is deeply troubling. The fact that it was not immediately thrown out is even more so.
Shrilay Sinha from Huddersfield wrote on May 30, 2022 at 7:01 pm
The initial decision was disgraceful, with no insight into how they reached it. Anything that is really going to help this colleague needs to be done! What is different about the appeal from the original hearing?
The initial decision was disgraceful, with no insight into how they reached it. Anything that is really going to help this colleague needs to be done! What is different about the appeal from the original hearing?
Bolaji Ibidun from Derby wrote on May 30, 2022 at 6:40 pm
Dr Arora, I’m sending you love and light 💡.
Dr Arora, I’m sending you love and light 💡.
Bolaji Ibidun from Derby wrote on May 30, 2022 at 6:40 pm
Dr Arora, I’m sending you love and light 💡.
Dr Arora, I’m sending you love and light 💡.
MARIAM AKHTAR from Birmingham wrote on May 30, 2022 at 6:37 pm
An utter abuse of GMC powers, and I’m angry that I am paying to support this organisation. So sorry you had to go through this ordeal. I hope you get a full apology from the GMC and they compensate you for what you have had to go through.
An utter abuse of GMC powers, and I’m angry that I am paying to support this organisation. So sorry you had to go through this ordeal. I hope you get a full apology from the GMC and they compensate you for what you have had to go through.
S from Newcastle upon Tyne wrote on May 30, 2022 at 1:57 pm
It is a fact that overseas qualified doctors and doctors of BAME Community are disproportionately subjected to GMC hearings and suspensions. This seems like a case of miscommunication rather than anything else. It is utterly ridiculous thay GMC wastes valuable resources on such matters. We stand with you Dr Arora
It is a fact that overseas qualified doctors and doctors of BAME Community are disproportionately subjected to GMC hearings and suspensions. This seems like a case of miscommunication rather than anything else. It is utterly ridiculous thay GMC wastes valuable resources on such matters. We stand with you Dr Arora
S vaghani wrote on May 30, 2022 at 1:14 pm
What a joke of a regulatory body GMC is. An absolute trivial matter , I can't believe they are wasting everybodys time, just so they can make an example of yet another minority group. A group of individuals making rules from their cosy little offices, so far removed from real life and real medicine. Absolutely speechless. There's only one reason why we have a shortage of doctors in the UK - don't think it takes a genius to figure out why. Dr Arora - keep fighting, you have immense support behind you.
What a joke of a regulatory body GMC is. An absolute trivial matter , I can't believe they are wasting everybodys time, just so they can make an example of yet another minority group. A group of individuals making rules from their cosy little offices, so far removed from real life and real medicine. Absolutely speechless. There's only one reason why we have a shortage of doctors in the UK - don't think it takes a genius to figure out why. Dr Arora - keep fighting, you have immense support behind you.
Ikenna Ogbu from Newcastle-under-Lyme wrote on May 30, 2022 at 1:00 pm
It’s extremely disappointing to see that this case made it to the level of an investigation by the GMC and resulted in suspension. Clearly, this is a patient safety issue that has been raised by the doctor to their employer as a result of not having the appropriate tools to work with. It is very saddening that anyone has to be governed by an organization that seems to sometimes handle issues without considering simple reason. Does this mean I have to be afraid of asking my employer for work tools? Surely not.
It’s extremely disappointing to see that this case made it to the level of an investigation by the GMC and resulted in suspension. Clearly, this is a patient safety issue that has been raised by the doctor to their employer as a result of not having the appropriate tools to work with. It is very saddening that anyone has to be governed by an organization that seems to sometimes handle issues without considering simple reason. Does this mean I have to be afraid of asking my employer for work tools? Surely not.
Roxane Stienstra from Glasgow wrote on May 30, 2022 at 12:33 pm
I honestly have no words for this ridiculous injustice. The only dishonest party here is the gmc abusing our money to punish someone for a minor communicative discrepancy. You have my full support and I'm thinking of you Dr Arora!
I honestly have no words for this ridiculous injustice. The only dishonest party here is the gmc abusing our money to punish someone for a minor communicative discrepancy. You have my full support and I'm thinking of you Dr Arora!
Julia Nikolaou - Thomas from London wrote on May 30, 2022 at 12:21 pm
The fact that this is even an issue directly has to do with racism and bullying in the workplace. Please let's focus on patient care - this needless pettiness hurts everyone.
The fact that this is even an issue directly has to do with racism and bullying in the workplace. Please let's focus on patient care - this needless pettiness hurts everyone.
Fahad khan from Altrincham wrote on May 30, 2022 at 12:14 pm
Fully support the doctor
Fully support the doctor
Clare from Staffordshire wrote on May 30, 2022 at 11:22 am
Shocked and outraged that a GP has been brought to attention regarding such a minor issue. Really GMC needed involvement. What’s next?
Shocked and outraged that a GP has been brought to attention regarding such a minor issue. Really GMC needed involvement. What’s next?
Parsley powersmith from Sheffield wrote on May 30, 2022 at 11:17 am
Fight the good fight and eventually you will get justice. So sorry this has happened to you. Stay strong!
Fight the good fight and eventually you will get justice. So sorry this has happened to you. Stay strong!
Mariya Ibrahim from Wolverhampton wrote on May 30, 2022 at 10:31 am
Dr Arora, I want you to know that majority of us doctors are rightly outraged at this grave miscarriage of justice. Why did you even need to ask for a laptop in the first place if you needed it to do your job? How could something so trivial amount to a suspension for dishonesty? I’m afraid the GMC/ MPTS lost their way here. You have my full support and we will push this as high as we can to get you justice.
Dr Arora, I want you to know that majority of us doctors are rightly outraged at this grave miscarriage of justice. Why did you even need to ask for a laptop in the first place if you needed it to do your job? How could something so trivial amount to a suspension for dishonesty? I’m afraid the GMC/ MPTS lost their way here. You have my full support and we will push this as high as we can to get you justice.
shona smith from Little Hulton wrote on May 30, 2022 at 9:59 am
Appalling treatment of someone who has served 30 years and should not have been expected to work without a laptop in the first place. Stinks of racism!
Appalling treatment of someone who has served 30 years and should not have been expected to work without a laptop in the first place. Stinks of racism!
Abi Coutinho wrote on May 30, 2022 at 9:25 am
The treatment of Dr Arora, by the GMC and her local trust, is completely disproportionate to her request and subsequent actions. At a time when retention and morale are at an all time low, it is not hard to see, with cases such as this, as to why. Ethnic minorities are not inherently ‘untrustworthy’ but are an essential part of the NHS and should be treated with equal respect to their white peers.
The treatment of Dr Arora, by the GMC and her local trust, is completely disproportionate to her request and subsequent actions. At a time when retention and morale are at an all time low, it is not hard to see, with cases such as this, as to why. Ethnic minorities are not inherently ‘untrustworthy’ but are an essential part of the NHS and should be treated with equal respect to their white peers.
Joseph Bae from Aylesbury wrote on May 30, 2022 at 9:03 am
MPTS is out of touch in this case. It is just a sign that how doctors are unfairly treated.
MPTS is out of touch in this case. It is just a sign that how doctors are unfairly treated.
Nnamani Chukwuemeka Christopher from Cumbria wrote on May 30, 2022 at 8:03 am
It is good to be supportive.
It is good to be supportive.
Adesegun Ajasa from London wrote on May 30, 2022 at 7:48 am
This is a ridiculous judgment and the suspension was very unfair and this is a likely stain to her records. She took the statement as best as she understood it and wasn’t quite dishonest in her recorded words. The GMC should quite revisit this judgement as Natives who have done worse have gotten away unpunished.
This is a ridiculous judgment and the suspension was very unfair and this is a likely stain to her records. She took the statement as best as she understood it and wasn’t quite dishonest in her recorded words. The GMC should quite revisit this judgement as Natives who have done worse have gotten away unpunished.
Dr Singh from Dorset wrote on May 30, 2022 at 7:14 am
This is surprising and. Shocking case,. There appears to be a communication barrier between the MD and Dr Arora. Remote working is a boon as evident during the Pandemic there is nothing wrong in asking for a Laptop. What really is upsetting that it is becoming blatant in any case hearing with GMC the Doctors view, circumstances, and reasons are Never taken into account especially if the Dr is Overseas trained Dr. I feel overseas Dr have to live in fear and May be in future they should be proactively Counselled for GMC’s Predeliction.
This is surprising and. Shocking case,. There appears to be a communication barrier between the MD and Dr Arora. Remote working is a boon as evident during the Pandemic there is nothing wrong in asking for a Laptop. What really is upsetting that it is becoming blatant in any case hearing with GMC the Doctors view, circumstances, and reasons are Never taken into account especially if the Dr is Overseas trained Dr. I feel overseas Dr have to live in fear and May be in future they should be proactively Counselled for GMC’s Predeliction.
Dr Chidinma Chimezie from Solihull wrote on May 30, 2022 at 2:46 am
The NHS is so broken and literally existing in the good will of the people working for it . To think that this is an issue what putting A fellow colleague through the drill of GMC is heart breaking. To also think that you are in a career where an essential tool that should be delivered to you before you start working is an issue that land you a suspension is soul destroying. I would like many be considering my options out of medicine.
The NHS is so broken and literally existing in the good will of the people working for it . To think that this is an issue what putting A fellow colleague through the drill of GMC is heart breaking. To also think that you are in a career where an essential tool that should be delivered to you before you start working is an issue that land you a suspension is soul destroying. I would like many be considering my options out of medicine.
Dr Sheena Yvonne Barnett from London wrote on May 30, 2022 at 2:28 am
This is honestly the most ridiculous thing I have come across. Is this truly what my GMC fees go towards? I wish hospital managers would concentrate on actual patient care.
This is honestly the most ridiculous thing I have come across. Is this truly what my GMC fees go towards? I wish hospital managers would concentrate on actual patient care.
Zada Zainal Abidin from Stuttgart, Germany wrote on May 30, 2022 at 1:13 am
Dear Dr Manjula Arora, Sending you love and support 100%. You were asserting your needs and being pro-active. Usually for women this would result in people calling us pushy or bossy, but to be called “liar” is a new low! Dr B’s actions to reinterpret his own words, his refusal to equip you with a necessary work item, and consequently to report you to the GMC gobsmacked me. Countersue him for damages!
Dear Dr Manjula Arora, Sending you love and support 100%. You were asserting your needs and being pro-active. Usually for women this would result in people calling us pushy or bossy, but to be called “liar” is a new low! Dr B’s actions to reinterpret his own words, his refusal to equip you with a necessary work item, and consequently to report you to the GMC gobsmacked me. Countersue him for damages!
Divya Samuel wrote on May 30, 2022 at 12:38 am
I am saddened to hear about this news and hope that you find all the support you deserve and get justice!! Happy to support you in whatever way possible ! Best wishes always
I am saddened to hear about this news and hope that you find all the support you deserve and get justice!! Happy to support you in whatever way possible ! Best wishes always
Rishikesh Parmeshwar from Lancaster wrote on May 30, 2022 at 12:22 am
This is a mindless act which beggars belief. This is just another in a series of illogical and punitive decisions taken by GMC in the recent past and will do no good to the already eroded confidence of its 'members' in the organisation. Shameful!
This is a mindless act which beggars belief. This is just another in a series of illogical and punitive decisions taken by GMC in the recent past and will do no good to the already eroded confidence of its 'members' in the organisation. Shameful!
Priya Suresh from Plymouth wrote on May 29, 2022 at 11:47 pm
This appears to be a simple case of miscommunication/ misinterpretation which should have been resolved locally — why refer to GMC!! And why suspension !!! I hope there is a positive outcome for Dr Manju Arora when the case is reviewed.
This appears to be a simple case of miscommunication/ misinterpretation which should have been resolved locally — why refer to GMC!! And why suspension !!! I hope there is a positive outcome for Dr Manju Arora when the case is reviewed.
Priya Suresh from Plymouth wrote on May 29, 2022 at 11:47 pm
This appears to be a simple case of miscommunication/ misinterpretation which should have been resolved locally — why refer to GMC!! And why suspension !!! I hope there is a positive outcome for Dr Manju Arora when the case is reviewed.
This appears to be a simple case of miscommunication/ misinterpretation which should have been resolved locally — why refer to GMC!! And why suspension !!! I hope there is a positive outcome for Dr Manju Arora when the case is reviewed.
Kinnary Martin from Cambridge wrote on May 29, 2022 at 11:41 pm
Utterly ridiculous response to something that could have been easily sorted out through effective communication and seeking to understand.
Utterly ridiculous response to something that could have been easily sorted out through effective communication and seeking to understand.
Mary O'Gorman from Birmingham wrote on May 29, 2022 at 11:14 pm
I am so sorry you have had to face this massive unwarranted investigation and appalling conclusion. It could have happened to any of us but hasn't and I fervently hope you get justice.
I am so sorry you have had to face this massive unwarranted investigation and appalling conclusion. It could have happened to any of us but hasn't and I fervently hope you get justice.
Dr Kirsten Riemer from Bucks wrote on May 29, 2022 at 11:10 pm
This seems utterly unfair and unjust.
This seems utterly unfair and unjust.
Ravindra Gokhale from Wirral wrote on May 29, 2022 at 11:04 pm
I demand refund of my annual GMC sub if it's wasted on investigating such a trivial matter which should've dealt and resolved locally in 5 mins. GMC should apologise to Dr Arora
I demand refund of my annual GMC sub if it's wasted on investigating such a trivial matter which should've dealt and resolved locally in 5 mins. GMC should apologise to Dr Arora
Dr Lucy Meadows from Beverley wrote on May 29, 2022 at 10:56 pm
This case is a dreadful abuse of power on the part of the unaccountable GMC, which is now harming the profession, damaging morale and has become unfit for purpose. Dr Arora has been targeted by her employer and wholly wrongfully treated by the GMC, which must be regulated and reformed. What a dreadful reflection of medicine in the UK.
This case is a dreadful abuse of power on the part of the unaccountable GMC, which is now harming the profession, damaging morale and has become unfit for purpose. Dr Arora has been targeted by her employer and wholly wrongfully treated by the GMC, which must be regulated and reformed. What a dreadful reflection of medicine in the UK.
Adeolu Arikawe from Leicester wrote on May 29, 2022 at 10:40 pm
Mrs Arora, as you go through this trying time, be assured that you are not alone. We would be standing with you all through the way.
Mrs Arora, as you go through this trying time, be assured that you are not alone. We would be standing with you all through the way.
Pushpo B Hossain from London wrote on May 29, 2022 at 10:02 pm
Dr M Arora, was doing her job and it was the company’s job to provide her with all the tools- if anyone that should have been referred - it should have been the employer who didn’t give her the laptop which was required to do her job- but instead referred her to the GMC. I’m concerned that my annual fees are being used to suspend hard working doctors like Dr M Arora! And what is the point of paying for indemnity if such things are happening. If it’s not about the Laptop- then what is it truly about? Is it about her ethnicity? Colour? We would like some answers from GMC please!
Dr M Arora, was doing her job and it was the company’s job to provide her with all the tools- if anyone that should have been referred - it should have been the employer who didn’t give her the laptop which was required to do her job- but instead referred her to the GMC. I’m concerned that my annual fees are being used to suspend hard working doctors like Dr M Arora! And what is the point of paying for indemnity if such things are happening. If it’s not about the Laptop- then what is it truly about? Is it about her ethnicity? Colour? We would like some answers from GMC please!
Elissa Abi-Raad wrote on May 29, 2022 at 9:36 pm
It is outrageous that a miscommunication/misunderstanding that can simply be resolved locally, has instead made it to the GMC and lead to this. All the support from a fellow BAME doctor. It is extremely important to raise this and make sure no other doctor goes through the same difficult process unnecessarily again.
It is outrageous that a miscommunication/misunderstanding that can simply be resolved locally, has instead made it to the GMC and lead to this. All the support from a fellow BAME doctor. It is extremely important to raise this and make sure no other doctor goes through the same difficult process unnecessarily again.
Ellen Welch from Carlisle wrote on May 29, 2022 at 9:28 pm
For this to be escalated to gmc/mpts and not settled at a local level is outrageous. You have our support at DAUK
For this to be escalated to gmc/mpts and not settled at a local level is outrageous. You have our support at DAUK
Matt Kneale from Manchester wrote on May 29, 2022 at 9:20 pm
It is scandalous that this issue to a suspension. This should never have been taken beyond a local resolution process, and the fact it was not thrown out well prior to a MPTS hearing, is testament to a broken process. Please appeal this outrageous judgement if you feel able to.
It is scandalous that this issue to a suspension. This should never have been taken beyond a local resolution process, and the fact it was not thrown out well prior to a MPTS hearing, is testament to a broken process. Please appeal this outrageous judgement if you feel able to.